Pool Filter Reviews and Comparisons – Residential

What Type And Size Is Best For You And Your Pool?
The purpose of the pool filter is to remove impurities such as dirt, leaves, grass, hair, body oils, sunscreen, and even many bacteria from the water.  Our high efficiency filters keep your pool water clean, clear, and inviting.
There is no arguing that Diatomaceous Earth (D.E) does the best job of filtering and clearing water. D.E filters are able to catch the smallest particles.  Cartridge filters do the next best job, and then Sand. There are however, some pro’s and con’s of all 3 types. While all will keep the water clear, one type is most expensive, A couple are easier to maintain, and one is better for the environment.
When you are finished with this examination, you should be able to select the pool filter that is most appropriate for your circumstances. Also, I will share my opinion, explaining which specific filters are best for cleaning and maintaining residential inground swimming pools, all without your eyes glazing over (hopefully).
Filter Types & Efficiency: Sand, D.E, & Cartridge
Sand Filters
Pro’s
Sand filters are the least expensive. They require the least amount of maintenance.  Sand media lasts 5 to 7 years.
Con’s
Sand filters are the least efficient, so clearing dirty pools takes longer. Not appropriate for super dusty areas like California and require extensive back wash cycles for cleaning, which wastes a lot of water. You may require longer run times to clear pools in high pollen areas. Longer run times means higher energy bills.  These are the least environmentally friendly based on both water and electric usage.
Cartridge Filters
Cartridge filters are the newest type of filter, and are the second best with its ability to grab particles @ 15 microns.
These fiber filter types have become extremely popular in the past few years, especially with above-ground swimming pools. Water enters the housing, water is them forced through the porous fiber cartridge material, trapping all particles larger than 15 Microns on the surface. Once the water makes it to the inner core, filtered water is directed back to the pool.
Pro’s
Cartridge filters are more efficient than sand. Require a lot less water to clean. These are the most environmentally friendly.
Con’s
Lacking a backwash cycle like the other filter types, you have to disassemble the filter every time the cartridge requires cleaning.  There are options on the type of assembly and some are a 5 minute clean and some are a ½ hr cleaning.  This obviously affects the cost of cleaning.
 D.E. Filters
D.E filters are the most efficient, they can catch particles as small as 4 microns. These filters are capable of giving you the cleanest and clearest water.
Pro’s
Clearest water possible! Clears dirty water fastest.
Con’s
Loss of water during backwashing. Requires new media (DE Powder) after every backwash. Most expensive to buy, and to maintain.
D.E backwash is not hazardous, but it does pose serious health risks in dry powder form, but that can be managed if handled in an open and well ventilated area. Basically, don’t breath it in, or get it in your eyes.

Bigger Is Better For A Reason
If your pool stays relatively clear and free of algae, just about any properly sized filter will work. But if your pool gets taken over by algae, you’re going to want a pool filter that is quick and easy to clean, and one that can handle the job. While no pool filter can keep up with live algae, once the algae is dead, you will need to filter a lot of suspended particles out of the water. For this reason I recommend going big!
The more you oversize your filter, the less maintenance you will have to do, and the longer it will last.
Whats The Best Pool Filter Type For Your Pool?
There is no escaping the fact that we are moving into a time in this valley, where we need to be more responsible, and preserve more water. If everyone went to cartridge filters, we would save millions, if not billions of gallons of water every year.
Filter Recommendations
I have given you all you need to know to make your choice.  No filter will work if it is not routinely cleaned.  Most units have a pressure valve that lets you know when cleaning is necessary.

For any additional questions, be sure to CALL DOUG – 760-409-3763
poolproblem@gmail.com
dougpoolproblems.com

Popular posts from this blog

Pool Electrical Issues

With so much concern over proper pool water circulation and filtration, it can be easy to forget that your pool's plumbing is only part of what makes up your entire pool system. There are plenty of components and pieces of pool equipment that rely on a properly functioning electrical system to work correctly. Everything from your pool lights to the pump and in some cases your pool heater rely on electrical connections. If there is a problem with the electrical system, it will usually require an expert to handle any pool electrical repairs in a safe and reliable manner. Below you'll find a few examples of issues that can be caused by faulty electrical connections. You should never attempt to fix these problems on your own, since working with electricity around water can be extremely hazardous. Underwater Light Bulbs Pool lights often last around 5 years, and usually just need a replacement bulb if they happen to go out. Unfortunately, sometimes chemicals in pool water ...
Read more

Is it Time for New Waterline Tiles?

A clean and well-maintained pool is a great feature to have on any property. Pool owners can take great pride in a pool that looks it's best at all times. In order to keep your pool looking great, it is important to make sure all pool features are well looked after. Whether they are in pristine condition, or if they have seen better days, your waterline tiles are often one of the more noticeable features in any pool. If you're considering whether or not to simply clean and repair, or replace your pool's waterline tiles, the following tips may help you determine whether or not it is time for new waterline tiles to be installed. Extent of Damage One of the major causes for waterline tile damage is the sun itself. Over the years, even the most well installed waterline tiles may start to break down after prolonged exposure to harsh sunlight. You may notice the color on the tiles has begun to fade. When this occurs, it is a good sign that the tile finish has also b...
Read more

Solving Common Pool Pump Issues

Every pool, whether it's a small above ground, or a large in-ground model, relies on the pump more than any other piece of pool equipment to function properly. When a pool pump starts to act up, pool owners may notice their pool water quality start to decline. When it comes to filtration and even consistent water temperature, your pool pump can make all the difference. Knowing how to spot a minor pump issue before it becomes a major problem can help pool owners save a lot of time, money and hassle spent trying to get the problem solved. At Pool Problems? we encounter a number of different pool pump issues every day, most of which are preventable. To help you stay ahead of the game and keep your pool pump functioning properly at all times, take a look at the helpful tips about what you can do to fix common pool pump issues before they become a major problem. Leakage In any plumbing system, leaks are usually a sign that something has, or is about to go wrong. Your pool'...
Read more